Wednesday, June 30, 2010
Wednesday, March 31, 2010
Differences between Mentoring and Coaching
Differences between Mentoring and Coaching
| |||||||||||||||||||||||
Focus
Mentors in either a formal mentoring program or informal relationship focus on the person, their career and support for individual growth and maturity while the coach is job-focused and performance oriented.
A mentor is like a sounding board, they can give advice but the partners is free to pick and choose what they do. The context does not have specific performance objectives. A coach is trying to direct a person to some end result, the person may choose how to get there, but the coach is strategically assessing and monitoring the progress and giving advice for effectiveness and efficiency.
Mentoring is biased in your favour. Coaching is impartial, focused on improvement in behaviour.
In summary, the mentor has a deep personal interest, personally involved—a friend who cares about you and your long term development. The coach develops specific skills for the task, challenges and performance expectations at work.
Role
Mentoring is a power free, two-way mutually beneficial relationship. Mentors are facilitators and teachers allowing the partners to discover their own direction.
"They let me struggle so I could learn." |
"Never provided solutions—always asking questions to surface my own thinking and let me find my own solutions." |
A coach has a set agenda to reinforce or change skills and behaviours. The coach has objective/goals for each discussion. In our study, the top four words chosen to best describe their mentor's dominant style were—friend/confidant, direct, logical, questioner.
Relationship
Even in formal mentoring programs the partners and mentor have choices—to continue, how long, how often, and our focus. Self-selection is the rule in informal mentoring relationships with the partners initiating and actively maintaining the relationship. If I'm you mentor, you probably picked me. In an organization your coach hired you. Coaching comes with the job, a job expectation, in some organizations a defined competency for managers and leaders.
Source of influence
The interpersonal skills will determine the effectiveness of influence for both coach and mentor. The coach also has an implied or actual level of authority by nature of their position, ultimately they can insist on compliance. A mentor's influence is proportionate to the perceive value they can bring to the relationship. It is a power free relationship based on mutual respect and value for both mentor and partners. Your job description might contain "coach" or you might even have that job title—it's just a label or expectation. "Mentor" is a reputation that has to be personally earned, you are not a mentor until the partners says you are.
Return
The coach's returns are in the form of more team harmony, and job performance. The mentoring relationship is reciprocal. There is a learning process for the mentor from the feedback and insights of the partners.
The ability to look at situations from a different perspective, I am a Generation X and he is in his 50's.
The relationship is a vehicle to affirm the value of and satisfaction from fulfilling a role as helper and developer of others. Mentors need not be an all-knowing expert—such a position could be detrimental. In our study the most significant thing the mentor did was "listened and understood me" and, "built my confidence and trust in myself, empowered me to see what I could do."
Arena
A great deal of informal mentoring is occurring, with at risk youth, in our schools, as well as in volunteer, not for profit and for profit organizations. If I am your mentor chances are you have chosen me to be of help with some aspect of your life. Coaching even in the sporting arena is task related—improvement of knowledge, skills or abilities to better perform a given task. Mentors are sought for broader life and career issues. The partners is proactive in seeking out mentors and keeping the relationship productive. The coach crates the need for discussion and is responsible for follow up and holding others accountable.
Conclusion
Coaching and Mentoring is not the same thing. Our results and experience support the conclusion that mentoring is a power free, two-way mutually beneficial learning situation where the mentor provides advice, shares knowledge and experiences, and teaches using a low pressure, self-discovery approach. Teaching using an adult learning versus teacher to student model and, being willing to not just question for self discovery but also freely sharing their own experiences and skills with the partners. The mentor is both a source of information/knowledge and a Socratic questioner. If I am your coach you probably work for me and my concern is your performance, ability to adapt to change, and enrolling you support in the vision/direction for our work unit.
If there is still doubt in your mind visualize how the conversation and relationship would be different if your manager scheduled a coaching discussion at 2:00 this afternoon to discuss your roles, responsibilities and expectations, versus if you called your mentor to discuss some things that you have been thinking about.
Tuesday, March 23, 2010
Monday, March 15, 2010
Scope/ Needs Analysis (e-learning)
Here are a few questions which can help you to do a scope analysis.
- What is expected of the online course?
- Are there remote students for the course?
- Will it replace or supplement existing training?
- What will the project cost?
- Is an online course the best choice?
- Who will continue maintenance?
- Will there be regular updates and changes? Should it be designed to incorporate changes easily?
- Who will finally approve the course? What are the expectations?
Thursday, March 11, 2010
The Beauty of English Language Undone
Friday, February 26, 2010
Thursday, February 18, 2010
Speech by Chetan Bhagat at Symbiosis
Don’t just have career or academic goals. Set goals to give you a balanced, successful life. I use the word balanced before successful. Balanced means ensuring your health, relationships, mental peace are all in good order. There is no point of getting a promotion on the day of your breakup. There is no fun in driving a car if your back hurts. Shopping is not enjoyable if your mind is full of tensions.
"Life is one of those races in nursery school where you have to run with a marble in a spoon kept in your mouth. If the marble falls, there is no point coming first. Same is with life where health and relationships are the marble. Your striving is only worth it if there is harmony in your life. Else, you may achieve the success, but this spark, this feeling of being excited and alive, will start to die. ……………….
One thing about nurturing the spark - don't take life seriously. Life is not meant to be taken seriously, as we are really temporary here. We are like a pre-paid card with limited validity. If we are lucky, we may last another 50 years. And 50 years is just 2,500 weekends. Do we really need to get so worked up? …………….
It's ok, bunk a few classes, scoring low in couple of papers, goof up a few interviews, take leave from work, fall in love, little fights with your spouse. We are people, not programmed devices..... ...." :)
"Don't be serious, be sincere."!!
Friday, February 12, 2010
How long does it take to create learning?
How long does it take to create different kinds of learning? Here are the answers extracted from several Brandon Hall Research reports. I have reconstruted them into an easy-to-read view; because so many people ask for this information.
Ratio for each Type of learning
34:1 Instructor-Led Training (ILT), including design, lesson plans, handouts, PowerPoint slides, etc.
33:1 PowerPoint to E-Learning Conversion. Not sure why it takes less time then creating ILT, but that’s what we discovered when surveying 200 companies about this practice
220:1 Standard e-learning which includes presentation, audio, some video, test questions, and 20% interactivity
345:1 Time it takes for online learning publishers to design, create, test and package 3rd party courseware
750:1 Simulations from scratch. Creating highly interactive content
Reference: http://brandon-hall.com/bryanchapman/?p=7
Saturday, January 23, 2010
Monday, January 11, 2010
Types of Knowledge
- Knowing about - news events, basics of a field, i ntroductory concepts i n a discipline
- Knowing to do - drive a car, solve a math problem, code a program, conduct research, manage a project
- Knowing to be - to embody knowledge with humanity (doing blended with consistency and daily existence), to be a doctor or psychologist (mannerism, professionalism), to be an ethical person, to be compassionate, to relate, to feel
- Knowing where - to find knowledge when needed,web search, library, database, an organization, and increasingly, knowing who to approach for assistance
- Knowing to transform - to tweak, to adjust, to recombine, to align with reality, to i nnovate, to exist at levels deeper than readily noticeable,to think. The “why of knowing” resides in this domain
Friday, December 11, 2009
Post Telangana Effect
In Q for new state
- Gorkhaland (West Bengal)
- Vidarbha (Maharashtra)
- Harit Pradesh (Uttar Pradesh)
- Bundelkhand (Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh)
- Bhojpur (Uttar Pradesh and Bihar)
- Saurashtra (Gujarat)
- Purvanchal (Uttar Pradesh)
- Mahacoshal (Orissa)
- Bodoland (Assam)
- Mithilanchal (Bihar)
- Coorg (Karnataka)
- Full statehood for Delhi
- Full statehood for Puducherry
Thursday, December 10, 2009
Death of a state
For couple of days there a lot of debate going on if we should have one Andhra Pradesh or divide the state. Last night the central government decided to move for two states. Here is a mail which I received from a friend of mine.









